Not my best cake in the picture above (read the story here), but the frosting was to-die-for. You do the real food math:
Real butter + real cream + real mineral-rich, tasty unrefined sugar
= really super good real food frosting
It is even better than frosting made from white sugar and āwhiteā butter. (My butter is yellow, yellow, yellow.)
I advise caution. You wonāt be able to stop licking your fingers, the bowl, the cake and anything this frosting touches.
Unless youāre like my sister, who would turn down cake for mashed potatoes and gravy any day. Nah. Youāre not, right?
Chocolate Buttercream Frosting
Real butter + real cream + real mineral-rich, tasty unrefined sugar
= really super good real food frosting.
Ingredients
- 1 cup grass-fed butter unsalted, softened, but not melted (2 sticks)
- 3-1/2 cups rapadura or sucanat, powdered*
- 1/2 cup cocoa powder
- 1/2 teaspoon sea salt
- 2 teaspoons vanilla extract
- 4 tablespoons cream or raw whole milk, divided
Instructions
-
Cream butter in mixer or food processor.
-
Sift together the sugar and cocoa powder, then add to the butter.
-
Blend to mix in.
-
Add salt, vanilla and cream.
-
Blend for a few minutes until smooth.
-
Add cream or milk, 1 tablespoon at a time for a thinner and smoother consistency.
-
Add more sweetener for a stiffer frosting.
-
Use immediately, or refrigerate for later.
-
If refrigerated, bring to room temperature to spread more easily.
Recipe Notes
Delicious atop the Sourdough Chocolate Cake.
*Whiz rapadura in blender until fine, fine, fine. It being fine is very important so you don't have crystals in your frosting.
We only recommend products and services we wholeheartedly endorse. This post may contain special links through which we earn a small commission if you make a purchase (though your price is the same).
Yum! Looks great Wardee.
Messing up is what makes us learn new things ā yesterday I tried to make spiced coffee. It. Was. HORRIBLE. This made me feel a lot better. Thanks! lol
My husband canāt eat chocolate, but the rest of your buttercream recipe looks like my favorite vanilla buttercream.
BTW, I love that sourdough chocolate cake recipe. I havenāt made it in awhile and should.
I did make sourdough spelt crepes today ā¦ yum! The kids gobbled them up and said they were as good as our familyās famous Swedish pancakes (made with white flour), which is a huge compliment. I did add a bit of sugar and vanilla, as we use in the Swedish pancake recipe. The sourdough crepes were actually easier to manage and turn on the griddle than the white flour pancakes.
Tomorrow, Iām going to try the crepes with only egg yolks, as my husband cannot eat egg whites. I havenāt done enough recipe experimenting to know how that will turn out but want to try since Swedish pancakes have been our Christmas morning tradition and its so sad that my husband canāt eat but a couple of the regular ones anymore. But sourdough bread is tolerated.
Anyway, long story to tell you that Iām following your example with the cake and will be possibly making a mess of a recipe, but hoping it will turn out.
Merry Christmas!
Wardee, you make me slobber.
Yum, yum! I havenāt made a sourdough chocolate cake in a long time, but this makes me want one so bad
With this icing on it of course! Looks delicious, Wardee 
Hi again ā¦ Iām just reporting that my crepes experiment worked. I separated the yolks, and increased the quantity of eggs used. I couldnāt tell any difference from yesterdayās batch.
Stacy, you make me laugh! <3
Do you have a back and forth button on your pages? If I am looking right over it I will slap my forehead! I am catching up with your site and canāt find it.
Kelli ā At the bottom of the blog page ( https://traditionalcookingschool.com/ ) thereās an older posts and newer posts button.
Otherwise, check out the archives for a chronological list: https://traditionalcookingschool.com/archives
I have not tried the frosting yet, but I DID make the sourdough chocolate cake and it was DELICIOUS!!!! It was as light and fluffy as a store-bought cake mix, but OH so much better, of course.
Now that I have an affordable source for raw butter and cream, I will be making this frosting! Thanks so much!
Could you use coconut sugar for this recipe?
Hi Beth,
That should work fine. Just be sure to whiz it in the blender as directed for the Rapadura. Let us know how it turns out!
Millie
GNOWFGLINS Support Team
Hi Wardeh, to make this vanilla frosting would I just omit the cocoa powder or up anything else? Thanks!
Hi Lorie,
Iāve made it vanilla with only omitting the cocoa powder, no other changes. It was wonderful!
Millie
GNOWFGLINS Support Team
How much frosting does this recipe make?
What about just vanilla? Iām guessing less since there isnāt the 1/2 C cocoa powder.
Thanks. ; )
Hi, Debbie.
To make vanilla frosting, I would just omit the cocoa powder. No other changes.
It should make about 2 cups.
~Makenzie, TCS Customer Success Team