The Best & Healthiest Flours For Sourdough #AskWardee 065

“What’s the best flour for sourdough?” asks Marie.

Marie also adds a few qualifications: it can’t be wheat, it has to be versatile and healthy, it should be as low starch and low glycemic as possible, and it should be frugal.

Ok, then… this is a tough one. 🙂

But we’re tackling it anyway on this week’s #AskWardee.

I broadcast #AskWardee live each Wednesday at 10am Pacific (1pm Eastern) on Periscope and Facebook Live. Both the podcast and video replay of this week’s show are below. Enjoy!

Subscribe to #AskWardee on iTunes, Stitcher, YouTube, or the Podcasts app.

The Question: What’s The Most Versatile, Most Frugal, Healthiest Flour For Sourdough?

Marie asks:

I am really confused and unsure which flour is best for me to make sourdough bread with. Amaranth, buckwheat, rye, teff, millet, quinoa, or can I use something like chickpea or flaxseed or brown rice? I have PCOS and need to watch my carbs and gluten. However, I am interested in making sourdough for my husband, and I want to occasionally enjoy a slice for myself, too. Just because the bread is mostly for him doesn’t mean I don’t want it as healthy as possible for him and me.

What I am looking for:

– suitable for sourdough starter
-as open as possible for a variety of bread products
-not mix it with white or whole wheat flour in order for it to work, mixing with another healthier grain is ok
-as cheap of a grain as possible
-least amount of gluten, wheat, and as low-glycemic as possible
-as nutritious, natural, and organic as possible

I know you use einkorn for your family. It’s tempting to just go with that because I know I could just follow your recipes to a T. Do you perhaps know what flour would be best for us under the terms I provided?

Thank you so much for your time. It is greatly appreciated. I am getting so spun around the more I read!

My Answer: The Healthiest Flour For Sourdough

Marie, that’s a tough list of qualifications — not all of which go together that well.

Mainly because the healthier and more off the beaten path you get, the more expensive you get, too.

Still… I think we’ll come up with something for you.

First, let’s discuss your options.

1. Flour Suitable For Sourdough Starter

Any flour with starch is going to be suitable for a sourdough starter. Because starch is the sugar, and that’s the food the starter needs.

Starters with gluten-free flours (like the ones you mentioned — amaranth, buckwheat, teff, millet, quinoa, brown rice, plus oats and others) often need help — it’s called a boosted starter. Where you add water kefir or Kombucha to them regularly to make them more bubbly and strong. There’s more info on that in this #AskWardee 009 — Gluten-Free Sourdough Starter Basics.

Starters with glutenous flours (wheat, rye, spelt, einkorn) tend to make more bubbly, active starters and don’t need a boost.

So, here… you could go with any of these. Non-wheat, of course.

2. Versatile In Baking

The gluten flours are going to be the most versatile in baking. If you take out the modern wheat, the next most versatile are spelt and einkorn (my favorites). They both make light baked goods and great breads. They don’t need to be mixed with other flours for your baked goods to turn out great (with a little bit of practice, of course).

Rye is not my favorite. It is hard to get right and turns out very dense unless blended with other flours.

The gluten-free flours work best if 4 to 5 of them are blended together and used in pastry baking — quick breads, muffins, cakes, cookies. They really, really need help with binding because they lack gluten. So eggs or chia seeds or flax seeds are really important to prevent a crumbly result.

They can make sourdough sandwich bread, too, but it’s usually not like making it with the gluten flours — just sayin’. There’s more info in my Allergy-Free Cooking eBook & Video Package.

 3. Doesn’t Need To Be Mixed With Wheat Flour To Work (Mixing With Other Flours OK)

I just answered this in the previous qualification so I won’t repeat myself.

4. Cheap

All the flours you’re mentioning are more expensive than wheat, though you may find good deals with a bit of shopping around.

Of the gluten flours that are still in the running — einkorn is more expensive than spelt, though I often see comparable prices here and there. If you’re a member of Traditional Cooking School or purchase the Einkorn Baking eBook & Video Package, you can save on those flours or grains through specials we’ve negotiated for you.

You’ll save money if buying the grains and grinding your own flour. For instance, here’s my favorite einkorn — the berries are $3.00/pound. (Members can save more using our special links.)

My no-knead einkorn sourdough bread needs about 1-1/2 pounds of flour, making the flour cost for the loaf $4.50 (at the price above, not counting any member discounts). Yes, it’s more than grocery store bread, but that’s an apples to oranges comparison given that store bread is so much less healthy than true homemade sourdough bread. The right comparison is to an artisan bakery price — which could be $5 to $8 or more per loaf.

Rye, though it’s harder to work with in breads and such, may be an option for feeding your starter since it is usually cheaper than spelt or einkorn.

I haven’t priced out the gluten-free flours. If you’re purchasing a pre-mixed blend, you’re likely to get more starch and pay a premium. You can mix your own at home. The price will depend on which 4 to 5 you choose — and the price might end up being comparable to spelt or einkorn anyway.

5. Least Amount of Carbs and Gluten & Is Lowest Glycemic

Ok, so first we need to talk about the fact that all these grains (both gluten and gluten-free) have carbs. It’s in the form of starch.

Since you have PCOS, the very best thing you can do (provided you can eat some starch) is to prepare all your grain-containing baked goods with sourdough — because the organisms in the starter eat the starch and reduce it. The more starch they consume, the lower the glycemic index (which is a ranking scale of how much sugar/starch affects blood-sugar levels).

As I discussed in a previous #AskWardee 035 — Is Sourdough Bread Low-Glycemic — the glycemic index of sourdough bread is 51, which is considered low on the glycemic index scale. (But it still has carbs, lest anyone forget!)

Here’s a quote from that episode, discussing sourdough bread’s glycemic ranking:

Based on the research I have seen, regular non-sourdough white bread has a glycemic index of 71 (that’s High GI), while sourdough bread has a glycemic index of 53 (that’s Low GI).

This means sourdough is a very effective method for lowering the glycemic index of the bread!

Yet, how does sourdough lower the glycemic index?

The bacteria and yeast consume the starches and sugars in the flour, so it has less starch when you eat it. Also, I saw research that suggested that the beneficial acids in sourdough (produced by the beneficial organisms in the starter) can help with blood sugar and digestion, too.

Just because sourdough bread is considered a low GI food does not mean one should eat to excess. A lot of bread is still a lot of bread.

One slice is still one serving of grains.

If you’re managing diabetes or blood sugar, you can (and should) decide what’s allowable for you.

And like with anything health-related, do your own research, pay attention to your body’s responses, and proceed with caution. One size does not necessarily fit all.

I would suggest also looking into ancient grains like einkorn. Einkorn has 1/2 the amount of starch as modern wheat. Combined with sourdough, I speculate your bread will be even lower than a GI of 53. (Though I don’t have proof of this… it’s just logical.)” —#AskWardee 035 Is Sourdough Bread Low-Glycemic?

As for gluten-free flours, I suspect they’re all similar — they will be high glycemic in un-soured bread. Which means in sourdough bread, you’ll have some reduction of starch but not all.

Also… keep in mind that commercial pre-mixed gluten-free blends contain high amounts of pure starch disguised as flours — potato and tapioca lead the bunch. These are super high on the glycemic index, higher than wheat even. And will still be so in sourdough bread, I think.

With all this mind, and knowing that I don’t have a definitive answer (who does the research on this stuff???), my safest conclusion for you is to use einkorn with sourdough. When and if you eat these types of foods, that is.

6. Most Nutritious

If you’re already avoiding modern wheat, that’s half the battle. Modern wheat has been hybridized (selectively bred) to produce high-gluten and high-yield plants. Many researchers have linked it to modern diseases.

Einkorn, on the other hand, is the oldest wheat variety we know (5,000 years old). It has less starch and gentler forms of it, as well as a gentler form of gluten. The other gluten-containing ancient grains — emmer, spelt, kamut — were all derived from einkorn. They are arguably healthier than modern wheat, yet still not the original form.

What about the gluten-free grains? If they are whole grains (not starches like potato and tapioca), I have heard nothing against their nutrition, provided you can eat them.

No matter what… select organic grains if you can. Perhaps locally from a farmer you trust. Or sourced from a small farm that others recommend or which has a good organic reputation.

If you avoid modern wheat and the gluten-free pure starches, I think you’ll find nutritious options.

The Bottom Line

If you take out the cost issue, the grains that stand out are:

Gluten flours — einkorn followed by spelt

Gluten-free flours — any of them, really — except the pure starch ones, and always blend 4 to 5 of them together for best results PLUS consider using a boosted starter (again see #AskWardee 009).

Now, price shop around those… to come up with what works best for you and your family.

Helpful Links:

• FREE no-knead einkorn sourdough bread
• How To Make A Sourdough Starter (FAQs, care tips, recipes & more!)
• Gluten-Free Sourdough Bread (with FREE Video)
• #AskWardee 035 Is Sourdough Bread Low-Glycemic?
• Gluten Intolerance and Sourdough: Is Sourdough Gluten-Free?
• 4 Reasons To Love Einkorn
• Einkorn 101
• Membership in Traditional Cooking School
• Einkorn Baking eBook & Video Package
• Allergy-Free Cooking eBook & Video Package
• Where to buy einkorn
• Feeding Your Sourdough More Than Just Flour!
• Debunking 4 Sourdough Myths (& How To Overcome Them)
• Is Aged Flour *Really* Better For Sourdough? #AskWardee 122

 

What are your favorite flours for sourdough and why?