• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Traditional Cooking School by GNOWFGLINS

Dish up the simple joy of healthy, down-home foods your family will LOVE… tonight.

Join 12,000+ families served since 2010!

  • Join Now
  • About
    • About Wardee & TCS
    • Our Team
    • FAQs & Help
    • Contact
  • Recipes
  • Blog
    • Recipes
    • Archives
  • Podcast
    • #AskWardee
    • Know Your Food with Wardee (retired)
  • Shop
    • Bible-Based Cooking Program
    • Print Textbooks
    • eBooks & eCourses
    • Recommended Tools & Supplies
    • More Books We Love
    • Complete Idiot’s Guide To Fermenting Foods
      • Errata
  • Login
You are here: Home » Food Preparation » Recipes » Condiments, Dips, & Spreads » Creamy Herbed Salad Dressing (THM:S, Egg-Free, No Mayo!)

Make a healthy dinner in 30 minutes or less... while spending $0 extra! Click here to get the Eat God's Way “30-Minute Skillet Dishes” worksheet + videos FREE!

Creamy Herbed Salad Dressing (THM:S, Egg-Free, No Mayo!)

We only recommend products and services we wholeheartedly endorse. This post may contain special links through which we earn a small commission if you make a purchase (though your price is the same).

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Rich, creamy, and herbed, this easy salad dressing makes your fresh, veggie-loaded greens sing! With a base of soft cheese or sour cream instead of mayo, it’s the perfect recipe for egg-free folks!

glass jar of white dressing with a spoon scooped into it. Text overlay says: "Creamy Herbed Salad Dressing (THM:S, egg-free & no mayo!)"

We’re on a quest to find the perfect homemade creamy salad dressing!

This simple dressing will make your fresh, veggie-loaded salads sing! It’s rich, filled with herbal goodness, and there’s no mayo… so it’s perfect for those with egg allergies.

How To Make Salad Dressing Without Mayo (Egg-Free!)

How to make creamy salad dressing without mayo, you ask? It’s so easy and the number of options may surprise you.

First, grab a Mason jar and choose your base ingredient.

1 cup measuring cup of sour cream

Pick one (or use a combination, if you like):

  • soft cheese, such as chevre, cream cheese, yogurt cheese, or kefir cheese
  • sour cream (pictured above)

These all have different consistencies. The key is to add raw milk to whichever one you’re using to get it to the consistency you prefer.

My recipe below reflects a thinner consistency, which is what we like because 1) it lasts longer and 2) it is easier to pour.

Our favorite dressing base is chevre or sour cream. The yogurt cheese or kefir cheese will make the dressing more tart, so you might want to decrease the apple cider vinegar and/or add a bit of raw honey.

For homemade soft cheese and sour cream recipes, see our Fundamentals eCourse. For more soft cheese recipes, check out the Cultured Dairy and Basic Cheese eCourse.

overhead shot of array of ingredients, including herbs, sour cream, and apple cider vinegar

Next, choose your favorite herbs.

In the recipe below you’ll see dill and parsley, plus my herbed seasoning salt blend. It’s so delicious and easy to make!

Feel free to use whatever combination of herbs you enjoy most or have on hand.

Finally, add the remaining ingredients and whisk well to combine.

It’s delicious right away but even better after some chill time in the fridge (be sure to read my best tips below).

This creamy salad dressing recipe is so versatile it’s sure to be your go-to for when you’re craving a creamy dressing.

5 Best Tips For Making The Perfect Creamy Salad Dressing

While bottled dressings are a tad bit more convenient, they pale in comparison to freshly-made salad dressings. Plus, using real, whole-food ingredients means a healthy and nourishing addition to your salads.

But, if your dressing doesn’t suit your taste buds you’re more likely to not use it. Here’s my 5 best tips for making perfect creamy salad dressing you’ll love to eat…

  1. Since yogurt or kefir cheese are tangy, feel free to add a bit of honey or other natural sweetener. Trim Healthy Mama plan followers, use stevia or another on-plan sweetening option.
  2. The flavors develop more as the dressing sits. You may want to give it a couple of hours before serving, then taste and adjust as needed.
  3. If you think you want more of a seasoning, wait until you’ve done #2 and tasted to make sure.
  4. Did you add too much of an herb or seasoning? Just add more base ingredient and adjust the rest of the seasonings to taste.
  5. Want to use fresh herbs instead? Remember the 3:1 ratio rule. You’ll need 3 times as much fresh herb as dried.

head of lettuce next to a jar of salad dressing

What Salad Is Best Served With Creamy Salad Dressing?

That all depends on your tastes, really. But definitely any big, leafy green salad loaded with your favorite veggies is perfect for a creamy salad dressing.

Other veggie salads, such as potato (or low carb cauliflower potato salad), pea, tomato and cucumber, or other mixed vegetable combinations are enhanced by using this flavorful, herbed dressing.

Or, try replacing the mayo in meat, fish, or egg salads with this dressing. You’ll get loads of flavor in one quick dollop and no need to get out extra ingredients.

Quick and easy meals? Yes please!

Can I Use Creamy Salad Dressing For Anything Other Than Salad?

Absolutely! It’s not just for lettuce salads.

woman's hand pouring salad dressing over pieces of chicken to marinate

Give these ideas a try:

  • Spread on a wrap instead of mayo.
  • Top a baked potato or sweet potato instead of plain sour cream.
  • Stir into a cream sauce.
  • Make it thicker and use as a dip for fresh veggies.
  • Use it as a marinade.
  • Soak chicken in it before frying.
  • Enjoy a dollop with roasted veggies of all kinds.

green salad on a plate with fresh veggies and a drizzle of dressing

Trim Healthy Mama Tips For On-Plan Creamy Salad Dressing

This dressing is perfect for the Trim Healthy Mama plan.

There are no inflammatory oils, no added sugars, and nothing artificial. Plus, using cultured, raw dairy gives you gut-healthy probiotics.

If you’d like to add a bit of sweetness, use pure stevia extract or erythritol.

Want to know if erythritol is OK for a traditional foods lifestyle? This article shares everything you need to know about the sugar alcohols, xylitol and erythritol!

This is a THM:S dressing so use in a low carb setting for best weight loss results. Since it’s made with dairy, it’s not suitable for a Deep S meal.

Now that you see how easy and delicious making your own healthy salad dressings is, you’ll want to keep a batch of this creamy dressing on hand at all times!

spoon scooped into a creamy white herbed salad dressing
4.34 from 6 votes
Print

Creamy Salad Dressing

Rich, creamy, and herbed, this simple dressing makes your fresh, veggie-loaded salads sing! This recipe calls for a base of soft cheese instead of mayo — perfect for egg-free folks! Makes 2 to 3 cups.

Course Dips & Spreads, Sauce
Cuisine American
Prep Time 8 minutes
Servings 20 servings
Calories 39 kcal
Author Wardee Harmon

Ingredients

  • 1 cup soft cheese such as chevre, cream cheese, yogurt cheese, or kefir cheese (or use 1-1/2 to 2 cups sour cream)
  • 1 cup raw whole milk plus additional if needed, for consistency (omit milk if using sour cream)
  • 1/4 cup raw apple cider vinegar
  • 2 teaspoons herbed seasoning salt or 1 teaspoon sea salt (plus more to taste)
  • 1 tablespoon dried dill
  • 1 tablespoon dried parsley
  • 1 pinch ground black pepper

Instructions

  1. Whisk all ingredients together -- in food processor, blender, or with a whisk by hand.

  2. Add additional milk as needed for consistency. I use 1/4 to 1/2 cup.

  3. Adjust seasonings to taste.

  4. Store in an airtight jar in the refrigerator.

Recipe Notes

5 Best Tips For Making The Perfect Creamy Salad Dressing

  1. Since yogurt or kefir cheese are tangy, feel free to add a bit of honey or other natural sweetener. Trim Healthy Mama plan followers, use stevia or another on-plan sweetening option.
  2. The flavors develop more as the dressing sits. You may want to give it a couple of hours before serving, then taste and adjust as needed.
  3. If you think you want more of a seasoning, wait until you’ve done #2 and tasted to make sure.
  4. Did you add too much of an herb or seasoning? Just add more base ingredient and adjust the rest of the seasonings to taste.
  5. Want to use fresh herbs instead? Remember the 3:1 ratio rule. You’ll need 3 times as much fresh herb as dried.
Nutrition Facts
Creamy Salad Dressing
Amount Per Serving (2 Tablespoons)
Calories 39 Calories from Fat 27
% Daily Value*
Fat 3g5%
Saturated Fat 2g13%
Cholesterol 6mg2%
Sodium 280mg12%
Potassium 29mg1%
Carbohydrates 1g0%
Fiber 1g4%
Sugar 1g1%
Protein 3g6%
Vitamin A 146IU3%
Vitamin C 1mg1%
Calcium 33mg3%
Iron 1mg6%
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.

More Salad Dressing Recipes!

spoonful of tangy tomato dressing being drizzled over a green salad

We’ve got more healthy homemade salad dressing recipes for you, too:

  • Creamy Sunflower Seed Salad Dressing (Dairy-Free)
  • Tangy & Sweet Tomato Salad Dressing (THM:S)
  • Probiotic Lemon-Garlic Salad Dressing Vinaigrette
  • Creamy & Easy Homemade Ranch Dressing
  • THM Probiotic Cucumber Ranch Dressing
  • 28 Fermented and Probiotic Salad Dressings

What herbs will you use in your creamy salad dressing?

This post was featured in 28 Fermented and Probiotic Salad Dressings.

This post was originally published and written by Wardee Harmon on 8/13/09. It was updated and republished on 6/29/20.

We only recommend products and services we wholeheartedly endorse. This post may contain special links through which we earn a small commission if you make a purchase (though your price is the same).

Posted in: Condiments, Dips, & Spreads Condiments, Dips, & Spreads (Gluten-Free) Cultured Dairy Fermenting & Culturing Food Preparation Recipes Salads Salads (Gluten-Free) Sauces Sauces (Gluten Free)

About Dawn Yoder

Dawn is a wife, homeschooling mom, and grandma who blogs at Oh Sweet Mercy. She loves learning, teaching, cooking, photography, crocheting, reading, and riding the Harley with her wonderful, hard-working hubby. She also has a small flock of chickens and constantly fights with a pack of shiny, sparkly squirrels.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. LeeLee says

    August 13, 2009 at 12:23 pm

    I like to whisk together balsamic vinegar, really good olive oil, a bit of old fashioned mustard, honey and some salt. simple, delicious & works best to wilt hearty leafy greens like swiss chard & kale for a very satisfying salad.
    .-= LeeLee´s last blog post… Livestock News =-.

    Reply
  2. Vanessa says

    August 13, 2009 at 1:00 pm

    This is great, Wardee. We just started buying raw milk products and they really make a difference. I added about 3-5 cloves of raw garlic which really enhanced the the dressing.

    Reply
  3. Tiffany says

    August 13, 2009 at 1:18 pm

    I like the combination of sour cream and plain yogurt in my creamy dressing. Along with dill, parsley, sea salt, black pepper, a little garlic and onion. I often use dehydrated garlic and onion. And then a little raw milk to thin it out.
    This is a new dressing I made recently. It is a little sweet, which I like sometimes.
    Asian Salad Dressing

    1/3 cup rice wine vinegar
    2 tbsp Tamari sauce
    ¼ tsp fresh ginger, minced
    1 small clove garlic, minced
    1 tbsp raw honey
    1 tsp sesame oil
    1 tbsp toasted sesame seeds
    Sea salt to taste

    Mix the vinegar, Tamari sauce and the honey together until the honey dissolves. Stir in the remaining ingredients. Pour over 4 cups fresh baby spinach, mix and serve.

    Reply
  4. Kendra says

    August 13, 2009 at 2:46 pm

    This isn’t a creamy dressing, but it our favorite homemade dressing so far:

    Honey Mustard Vinegrette

    1/2 Cup raw apple cider vinegar
    1/3 Cup olive oil
    1/4 Cup flaxseed oil
    2 t stone ground mustard (or your favorite mustard)
    1 T raw honey
    1/2 t salt (or herbamare, have done it both ways)
    1/2 t dried parsley or 1 t fresh parsley
    1/2-1 t dill (this is optional. I love dill, so I use it sometimes)

    You can really use whatever herb combination you like. I’ve experimented with all kinds of combos, but this is my favorite.
    .-= Kendra´s last blog post… The Perfect Start =-.

    Reply
  5. Kimi says

    August 13, 2009 at 9:28 pm

    That looks divine! Thanks for sharing!
    .-= Kimi @ The Nourishing Gourmet´s last blog post… Pennywise Platter Thursday 8/13 =-.

    Reply
  6. Wardee says

    August 14, 2009 at 5:30 am

    Great ideas, everyone! I’m going to try out these recipes – I think we’d love them.

    Reply
  7. Nanci says

    August 14, 2009 at 7:48 pm

    Our last batch of bacon-fat mayo (Darcey’s recipe) ended up with way too much lemon in it. It makes a super salad dressing though!

    Reply
  8. Jami says

    August 15, 2009 at 11:17 am

    Well Wardee you already know about our favorite salad dressing *grin*

    It uses mayonnaise, because I didn’t have access to any good milk or milk products until just recently…. So I’m excited to try some of my RAW milk products in place of the mayo!

    I call it Green Garden Dressing (should have a slight green color)

    2 cups organic mayo (or your better raw milk product)

    1 cup organic balsamic or red wine vinegar
    * IF NOT using mayo, add 2 teaspoons sea salt or tamari

    1/8 of a cup green stevia

    2 Tablespoons Spike or other non-salt spice mix

    Ummy additions: fresh herbs, garlic, chives and mild chili peppers from your garden!

    Put all the ingredients into a quart jar.
    Using a hand blender (wand) blend until smooth.
    Stir before serving, if to thick add a bit of water, stir again.
    Store in the refrigerator.

    I’m getting hungry now…. We also use this dressing on corn tortillas melted with cheese, and as a base for dips.

    Blessings

    Reply
  9. Katie says

    February 5, 2010 at 1:09 pm

    The best part of this is definitely its versatility! You teach people how to make their own and make it their own at the same time – Thank you so much for linking up!

    🙂 Katie

    Reply
  10. Elizabeth says

    February 17, 2010 at 6:08 am

    I really love this salad dressing! I did not have all the particular spices or the nutritional yeast, so I had to come up with my own variation on that, but the base ingredients were exactly what I was looking for. I didn’t make quite enough yogurt cheese, so I had to use also some sour cream in addition to the raw milk. I wasn’t sure what I would think about the apple cider vinegar gave it just the *tang* that I literally crave.

    Thanks! Now I’m excited to try some of your other recipes. 🙂

    Reply
  11. Connie Fletcher says

    May 12, 2010 at 1:33 pm

    Thanks for all the recipes. My favorite creamy “Ranch” dressing so far is to take 1 cup of kefir cheese. 1 cup homemade mayo, salt, pepper, dried dill, dried onion powder, dried garlic powder and mix it together. Makes a yummy healthy ranch type, even process in a seeded cuke…………

    Reply
  12. Maureen says

    August 4, 2010 at 10:05 pm

    Wardee,

    Is it okay to add fresh herbs to this dressing? I have some chives and other herbs in my garden and would love to put them to use this way. 🙂 Just wondering if there is a reason they might need to be dried.

    Thanks!

    Maureen

    Reply
    • Wardee says

      August 5, 2010 at 8:33 am

      Maureen – Definitely! And how wonderful! Use at least 3 times the amount when subbing fresh for dried (I’m sure you know that).

      Reply
  13. Katie G. says

    July 24, 2012 at 12:02 pm

    Thank you for the inspiration on how to make your own creamy dressing! This is just the sort of “recipe” I love to use. I use mainly dill, parsley, chives, and garlic to flavor it, and one or two other herbs in smaller amounts. The first time I made it everyone said it tasted like blue cheese dressing. Hopefully the batch I just set in the fridge will be equally well received.

    My “usual” dressing is a mix of herbs, which change every time, in 2/3 cup olive oil and 1/2 cup vinegar (usually 1/4c ACV and 1/4 another flavorful one). Sometimes mustard. If I’m afraid my family won’t like it I add about a tablespoon or less of honey or maple syrup, and everyone always loves it. I’m not always good at tossing stuff in something and it turning out delicious (though I still try…), so I’m very proud of my dressings.

    Reply
  14. Elizabeth from the Berkshires says

    August 15, 2013 at 4:07 am

    Hi Wardeh,
    I was wondering–is there a reason to make kefir cheese then add milk in? Would it work to just use kefir? Is it purely for flavor? It seems like removing liquid then putting it back in.
    Enjoying your blog, your podcast, and your online classes. Thanks for all the resources and knowledge you are sharing!
    Elizabeth

    Reply
    • Wardee Harmon says

      August 22, 2013 at 7:41 am

      Elizabeth — Adding a bit of milk to the kefir cheese sweetens it up. Kefir is pretty tart. Plus it makes it a dressing consistency. You could start with kefir (not kefir cheese) for sure, but the dressing would be more tart.

      Reply
4.34 from 6 votes (6 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Hi and Welcome!

I’m Wardee Harmon and I help Christian families who know they should eat healthy but are tired of complicated, time-consuming, weird-tasting, and unsustainable “healthy” diets…

…who want to look and feel better, save time and money, and have more energy for enjoying family life and serving Him fully!… like I was. Click here for more…

Recently on the Blog

  • Fizzy Apple Cider Switchel (VAD)
  • VitaClay Review & Buyer’s Guide
  • How to Make Healthy Cookies #AskWardee 006
  • Bean and Barley Soup (Instant Pot, Stove Top)
  • Soaked Spelt Banana Bread (VAD)
  • Ancient Grains 101
  • How to Heal Digestive Issues Naturally (Leaky Gut, SIBO, IBS, Celiac & more)
  • How To Meal Plan In 4 Easy Steps (KYF103)
  • Debunking 4 Sourdough Myths (& How To Overcome Them)
  • How To Use A Pressure Cooker 101

Recently Commented

  • YTmp3 on Homemade Sauerkraut In A Stoneware Crock
  • AJ on Homemade Dog Food In The Instant Pot
  • Ali on Rhubarb Salsa
  • Leif on Amish Butter: Really?
  • Makenzie Reed on How To Make An Herbal Eye Pillow For Relaxation & Headache Relief
  • Missy on How To Make An Herbal Eye Pillow For Relaxation & Headache Relief
  • Anonymous on 3 Dangers Of Cast Iron #AskWardee 137

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

Before Footer

g-NOWF-glinz

…are what we eat! God’s Natural, Organic, Whole Foods, Grown Locally, In Season.

We love working with other Christian families who love good food and want to eat according to God’s design…

Not only because we believe it’s the healthiest way, but because we want to give Him glory for creating good food as the best medicine!

Learn more about GNOWFGLINS here…

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IOcH27DM1dI

Eat God’s Way Cooking Program

Our Eat God’s Way cooking program is for Christian families who know they should eat healthy but are tired of complicated, time-consuming, weird-tasting, and unsustainable “healthy” diets…

…who want to look and feel better, save time and money, and have more energy for enjoying family life and serving Him fully!

Join 12,000+ families served since 2010! Learn more here…

Copyright © 2025 Traditional Cooking School by GNOWFGLINS • About • Help • Privacy • Partners

photo collage of a green salad drizzled with dressing, and a jar of dressing, with text overlay: "Creamy Herbed Salad Dressing (THM:S, egg-free, no mayo!)"

Rate This Recipe

Your vote:




A rating is required
A name is required
An email is required

Recipe Ratings without Comment

Something went wrong. Please try again.